Desiring Perfect Products Creates Waste

Altering consumer attitudes about minor flaws could keep usable items out of landfills

Based on the research of Rajagopal Raghunathan

iStock 1156950789

When do we decide that an item is no longer usable? In India, “people don’t just throw things away — they continue to use it until it rips,” says Rajagopal Raghunathan, professor of marketing and H.E. Hartfelder/The Southland Corporation Regents Chair for Effective Business Leadership at the McCombs School of Business at The University of Texas at Austin.

Americans, on the other hand, toss 50 million tons of durable goods in a single year, according to the Environmental Protection Agency. Much of it is repairable or reusable.

What drives the psychology of disposal? In new research, Raghunathan — with former McCombs doctoral student Aprajita Gautam, now of Texas A&M University, and Rebecca Walker Reczek of Ohio State University — identify a key trait: desire for a perfect product (DPP).

You might think people who care about getting the best products would also care to keep them longest. The researchers found something different.

High-DPP consumers were less willing to keep, repair, or donate items that had slight defects but still worked fine. They were more willing to upgrade to a newer version of a product, even when the upgrade offered no real improvement. Both habits add to waste, Raghunathan says.

But the situation is not hopeless, he adds. Understanding DPP can help with encouraging consumers to retain, maintain, or reuse more of their belongings.

Definition of Perfection

What is a perfect product? The researchers began by asking consumers to describe it. They distilled their answers into three characteristics of DPP.

  • A richer, more demanding picture of what the ideal product should be.
  • A tendency to raise that ideal when they see a better product.
  • Heightened sensitivity to even minor flaws, which makes them quicker to see products as faulty.

The researchers developed an eight-item scale for measuring a person’s DPP. They then tested how high levels affected behaviors toward a range of products, from coffee mugs to clothing to new technology.

In one experiment, researchers amassed items from a used clothing drive. They asked 315 participants to sort them into two bins: donating or recycling. The result: The higher a person’s  DPP score, the fewer items they were likely to put in the donation bin.

Environmentally, donating is preferable, since it extends the life of the garment. But a high-DPP person views it differently, Raghunathan says. “Chances are, they look at it and say, ‘This is not perfect, so nobody else is going to want it.’”

DPP can weaken other tendencies around keeping used items. The “endowment effect,” for example, makes a consumer unwilling to part with something they already own — even a small item such as a coffee mug. But people who rated high for DPP were more likely to swap the item if it was slightly flawed.

“That endowment effect is being eaten into by this flaw in the product,” Raghunathan says.

Reframing Imperfections

What stimulates DPP? One factor, the researchers conjecture, is social media. “There is this tendency to portray one’s life on social media as perfect,” Raghunathan says.

For marketers selling a new Lexus or a new iPhone, identifying high-DPP consumers might help target potential customers. But the study also can help policymakers encourage people to hang on to products longer, Raghunathan says.

In one experiment, high-DPP consumers were more accepting of an imperfect product if those flaws were framed as making it unique, such as a collector’s edition or something handmade. Raghunathan compares the attitude to the Japanese philosophy of wabi-sabi, which recognizes beauty in imperfection.

Another solution might be to offer subscription plans for high-end products to help extend their lives — such as servicing a car or steaming a rug.

Says Raghunathan, “They might, in fact, be more willing to pay up front in order to maintain a product at a kind of a lofty perch.”

“The Desire for Perfect Products” is published in Journal of Consumer Research.

Story by Hope Reese