More Medical Data Needs More Shared Understanding

To get the most out of electronic health records, teams must interpret and use them in the same way

Based on the research of Jay Park

iStock 1496103634

The shift from paper documents to electronic health records (EHRs) in healthcare has taken decades. Thanks to federal incentive payments for digitizing records, 9 out of 10 doctors’ offices  were using EHRs by 2021.

But clinics and hospitals are still figuring out how to use them to improve patient outcomes. New research from the McCombs School of Business at The University of Texas at Austin can give them some fresh ideas.

Access to EHRs can streamline patient care by letting nurses make decisions that previously required physicians, finds Jay Park, assistant professor of management. But there’s a catch: To be most effective, doctors, nurses, and technicians need to interpret the records in the same way.

“It becomes more important to be on the same page, to share understandings of that information itself,” Park says.

Seeing Info Eye to Eye

Prior research has shown that information technology decentralizes healthcare decisions. If a nurse doesn’t have to get information from a doctor, the nurse can make certain medical decisions more independently.

But Park saw a potential problem. When more clinicians can look at the same health data, “doctors and nurses may have very different understandings,” he says.

To assess the problem — with John Joseph and Daniel Chow of the University of California, Irvine, and Alex James Wilson of the University of North Carolina — Park analyzed 22,741 records of patient encounters in a university health system that had installed an EHR system in 2013.

Two of its hospitals adopted the system three months apart, allowing him to compare the one that had EHRs first with the one that didn’t.

He found that EHRs did decentralize information. After they were adopted, nurses made more medical decisions.

  • They wrote an average 55% more orders per patient encounter.
  • Their share of all medical decisions increased from 14% to 22%.

“We found that doctors delegate work to nurses, and nurses become more equipped to assume their tasks,” Park says.

Next, the researchers examined how to promote common understandings. They found three factors that led to nurses writing more orders.

  • Working together. Says Park, “Teams rotate a lot, and the more you work with the same person repeatedly, the more you know their working style.”
  • Common training. Sharing training on task procedures such as patient handoffs, daily schedules, and unit routines helps workers use EHRs in the same ways. That’s especially important if someone has used them in a previous job and needs to unlearn old habits.
  • Clinical notes. Clinical notes often contain idiosyncratic language that reflects individual clinicians’ interpretations. Regular use of these notes helps team members develop a shared understanding of one another’s vocabulary and context.  

The findings aren’t limited to healthcare, Park says. They could apply to teams in other industries, from engineers to marketers.

“Even though they have access to the same data, they could interpret it differently, and then they could have coordination problems,” he says.

Understanding AI?

Next up, he will be studying a newer kind of implementation challenge in healthcare: artificial intelligence.

“AI can dramatically expand access to information and help people analyze it quickly,” he says. “At the same time, AI requires more interpretation. Two employees, even if they receive the same AI output, could have a very different understanding of how it came to make the decision.

 “An important question is whether AI helps create shared understanding, or it creates more conflict over interpretation. Does it disrupt the decision-making process? I hope to find out.”

“Information Processing, Mutual Understanding, and Organization Design in Healthcare” is published in Strategic Management Journal.

Story by Omar Gallaga